Behind the Supportive DMs

Why Some Women Cheer Privately but Stay Silent Publicly

By MindBodySpiritss

Educational note: This blog is for reflection and educational purposes only. It is not therapy, diagnosis, mental health treatment, medical advice, or a substitute for working with a qualified professional.

Recently, I recorded an interview with Zainab Wadood, founder of The Z Philosophy (@the_zphilosophy), and she brought up a question that stayed with me.

She is a successful woman using her platform to bring women’s voices to the surface, especially the voices of women who may be afraid to speak, unsure how to speak, or still learning the vocabulary to express what they have carried silently.

During our conversation, she shared something many women leaders, founders, advocates, creators, and truth-tellers experience: she receives many supportive DMs behind the scenes, but not as many public voices standing beside her.

Women encourage her privately. They agree privately. They thank her privately. They tell her, “You are so courageous.” They may even say, “Thank you for saying what I could not say.” But when it is time to stand beside her publicly, on the stage, in the room, in the comments, in the meeting, or in the community, many become quiet.

They support behind closed doors. They cheer from behind the curtain. They agree in private. But they do not always stand on the stage with her.

And then she asked me, “Why do women do that?”

Explore how people-pleasing affects your voice and visibility →

My first response was honest, but incomplete. I thought, maybe they do not feel courageous enough to speak up publicly yet. Maybe they are supporting the woman who is willing to take the public risk because they are not ready to take that risk themselves.

But the more I sat with that answer, the more I knew it was too simple.

It would be unfair to place all women into one category. Human beings are complex. Women are complex. Our voices are shaped by personality, childhood experiences, attachment patterns, trauma, culture, family systems, community expectations, workplaces, relationships, and the lessons we learned long before we had the words to explain them.

From my previous clinical work, my current non-clinical work, and my personal life, I have learned that there is rarely one simple answer. So maybe the deeper question is not simply: “Why do women not speak up?”

Maybe the deeper question is: what has made public visibility feel unsafe for some women, even when they deeply agree in private?

Learn how attachment patterns shape your relationships and voice >

Private support is still support, but it is not the same as standing beside someone

There is something meaningful about a private message that says, “I see you. I agree with you. Thank you for saying what I could not say.”

That kind of support can be sincere. It can come from admiration, relief, grief, recognition, or resonance. Sometimes a woman sees another woman speaking publicly and thinks, “She is saying exactly what I have carried quietly for years.”

But private support has limitations.

A supportive DM may comfort the woman who is speaking, but public support helps shift the room. Private encouragement may validate her, but visible solidarity helps share the emotional weight, the risk, and the responsibility.

Still, before we judge the women who stay quiet, we have to ask what may be happening underneath that silence.

Some women are not silent because they do not care

Some women are silent because speaking up has never felt safe.

Many women were raised to be agreeable, pleasant, respectful, and quiet. They may have been praised for keeping the peace and corrected when they challenged something.

They may have heard: “Do not be too loud.” “Do not embarrass the family.” “Do not challenge authority.” “Be nice.” “Stay respectful.” “Do not make people uncomfortable.” “Keep the peace.”

A girl who grows up with those messages may become a woman with strong opinions, deep values, and a clear sense of what is right. But her body may still react as if speaking publicly is dangerous.

This is where a trauma-informed lens can help us slow down. We are not diagnosing anyone.

We are simply recognizing that a woman’s relationship with her voice may be shaped by what happened when she used it before.

For some women, silence was not weakness. Silence was survival.

If speaking up once led to punishment, rejection, humiliation, gossip, abandonment, or isolation, the body remembers. Even years later, when she wants to speak, something inside her may whisper: “Not me. Not yet. It is not safe.”

Executive coaching for women leaders: Build authentic confidence and visibility >

Attachment can shape how a woman uses her voice

The way we learned to seek safety and connection in relationships can influence how we show up publicly.

Some women fear losing approval. They may agree with the message, but public support feels risky because they worry about rejection, conflict, or being misunderstood.

They may think: “What if people get upset with me? What if I lose relationships? What if I am judged? What if I no longer belong?”

So they send the private message instead. Their support is real, but public agreement feels emotionally unsafe.

Other women may avoid emotional visibility altogether. They may care deeply, but standing beside someone publicly feels too exposing. They may tell themselves, “I do not want to get involved,” even when they agree.

Some women feel both: the desire to speak and the fear of what could happen if they do. One part of them wants to stand up.

Another part expects consequences. So they retreat.

And some women are not silent because of fear at all. They may be choosing timing, protecting their energy, navigating workplace politics, or deciding what is truly theirs to speak on.

Not every silence means the same thing.

Sometimes silence is fear. Sometimes silence is strategy. Sometimes silence is self-protection.
Sometimes silence is a boundary. Sometimes silence is a pause before a more thoughtful response.

The point is not to excuse all silence. The point is to understand that silence can come from many different places.

Relationship coaching: Develop secure attachment and authentic communication >

The body may react before the voice can speak

We often talk about speaking up as if it is only about courage.

But sometimes the body reacts before the mind can choose courage.

Some women freeze. They want to speak, but the words disappear. Their throat tightens. Their thoughts become foggy. Later, they may replay the moment and wonder, “Why did I not say something?”

Some women try to keep everyone comfortable. They agree privately with one person but stay publicly neutral because they do not want to upset anyone else. This may not be manipulation. It may be a learned way of staying safe.

Some women avoid the whole conversation. They do not comment, repost, attend, respond, or engage. Not because they do not care, but because the situation feels socially, emotionally, or professionally risky.

Courage matters. But courage grows better when there is safety, language, support, and practice.

Some women do not have the vocabulary yet

There are women who feel injustice before they can explain it.

They know something is wrong. They feel it. They recognize it. They agree with the womanspeaking.

But they may not have the words yet.

This matters.

Voice is not only volume. Voice is vocabulary.

Voice is knowing how to say, “I disagree,” without falling apart. Voice is knowing how to name harm without being consumed by anger. Voice is knowing how to hold your ground without losing yourself. Voice is knowing how to be direct without feeling cruel. Voice is knowing how to set a boundary without drowning in guilt.

Many women were taught how to be polite, helpful, accommodating, and pleasant. Far fewer were taught how to be clear, firm, honest, and visible without feeling unsafe.

So when they see another woman speaking with clarity, they may gather behind her because she has language they are still learning.

Some women are calculating real consequences

We also have to be honest: public support can cost women something. It can cost relationships. It can cost opportunities. It can cost reputation. It can create tension in families, workplaces, communities, and social circles.

For women in tightly connected communities, public agreement may not feel like a simple personal choice. It may feel like something that could affect their family, job, marriage, children, reputation, or future opportunities.

This does not mean silence is always right. But it does mean the risk is not always imaginary.

Some women are not only asking, “Do I agree?” They are also asking, “Can I afford the consequences of being seen agreeing?”

That question deserves compassion, even when the silence still needs reflection.

Executive coaching for women: Navigate career visibility and workplace dynamics >

Sometimes the woman on stage becomes a mirror

The woman who speaks publicly often becomes a mirror.

She represents courage, but she also represents exposure.

Other women may admire her and feel uncomfortable at the same time. Not because they are bad women, but because courage can awaken grief.

When a woman says out loud what another woman has swallowed for years, it can bring up many emotions: inspiration, shame, sadness, regret, envy, relief, and fear.

A woman may think, “I wish I could speak like that.” Or, “Why could I not say that before?” Or, “What would happen to me if I became that visible?”

Sometimes the woman on stage is not being rejected. She is being avoided because she awakens something unfinished in others.

Not every quiet woman is against you

When a woman is speaking publicly and feels alone, silence can feel like betrayal.

And sometimes, it is.

There are moments when silence protects harmful systems. There are moments when private agreement without public action allows one woman to carry the risk for many.

But not every quiet woman is careless. Not every woman behind the scenes is cowardly. Not every woman in the DMs is hiding for the same reason.

Some are healing. Some are learning. Some are afraid of conflict. Some are protecting themselves. Some are financially or socially vulnerable. Some have been punished for speaking before. Some are still trying to believe their voice matters. Some agree with the message, but are not ready for the visibility that comes with it.

Compassion allows us to see the whole person without removing accountability.

The invitation is not shame. The invitation is growth

A confrontational approach may ask, “Why are you hiding?”

A more compassionate approach asks, “What would help you feel safe enough, supported enough, and ready enough to become a little more visible?”

That question changes the conversation.

The goal is not to shame women for not being loud enough. The goal is to invite women into smaller, more courageous steps.

Public voice does not always begin with a speech, a stage, or a bold declaration.

Sometimes it begins with a comment. A repost. A conversation.

A boundary. A sentence in a meeting. A hand raised. A quiet but clear, “I agree with her.” A private message that becomes a public sentence. A moment of choosing not to disappear.

For some women, that first visible step is enormous.

Ready to build your voice and authentic presence? Book a free consultation with a coach

We need more than private applause

The woman who speaks should not have to carry the entire weight of the truth alone.

Behind-the-scenes encouragement can be meaningful, but if every woman stays behind the scenes, the woman on stage becomes the shield for everyone else’s unspoken convictions.

That is not sustainable. And it is not fair.

Women who use their voices publicly are often called difficult before they are called courageous. They are misunderstood before they are celebrated. They absorb criticism, discomfort, projection, and backlash that others are not ready to face. So yes, send the supportive DM.

But also ask yourself: is there one small public way I can stand beside her?

Not for performance. Not for attention. Not to prove courage.

But because visible support tells the woman speaking, “You are not alone.” And it tells the room watching, “She is not the only one who sees this.”

Explore our women’s coaching services and start your journey >

A softer way forward

Maybe the question is not, “Why do women not support women?”

Maybe the deeper question is, “What kind of safety, language, healing, and courage do women need in order to support each other more visibly?”

That is the conversation worth having.

Because women do support women. Many do it privately, quietly, carefully, and sincerely.

But the next layer of growth is learning how to move some of that support from behind closed doors into shared spaces.
Not every woman is ready for the stage.

But perhaps more of us can stop leaving one woman there alone.